Between Principle and Practice: Human Rights in North-South by David Gillies

By David Gillies

A comparative research of the discrepancy among government's phrases and activities with reference to human rights coverage. This paintings examines the human rights international relations of Canada, the Netherlands, and Norway, all wealthy business democracies with a global attractiveness for protesting human rights abuses, from the mid-1980s to the early-1990s. the writer finds that even those international locations are seldom ready to sacrifice short-run fiscal or political pursuits to protest gross and systematic human rights abuses past their border. in response to case reports of 5 3rd international international locations - Sri Lanka, the Phillippines, China, Indonesia, and Surinam - the publication explores the level which coverage ideas have been utilized in perform, exhibiting that constant, co-ordinated, and principled motion is elusive even for nations with a name for internationalism. the writer highlights the starting to be rift among North Atlantic democracies and rising Asian fiscal powers, the effectiveness of utilizing relief sanctions to safeguard human rights, and the vicissitudes of human rights programming in rising democracies.

Show description

Read or Download Between Principle and Practice: Human Rights in North-South Relations PDF

Best canadian books

Becoming My Mothers Daughter: A Story of Survival and Renewal

Changing into My Mother’s Daughter: a narrative of Survival and Renewal tells the tale of 3 generations of a Jewish Hungarian kin whose destiny has been inextricably sure up with the turbulent historical past of Europe, from the 1st global warfare throughout the Holocaust and the communist takeover after international warfare II, to the family’s dramatic break out and emmigration to Canada.

Alex Lord's British Columbia: Recollections of a Rural School Inspector, 1915-1936

Alex Lord, a pioneer inspector of rural BC colleges stocks in those reminiscences his reviews in a province slightly out of the level trainer period. traveling via great northern territory, using unreliable transportation, and enduring climatic extremes, Lord grew to become conversant in the aspirations of distant groups and their religion within the humanizing results of tiny assisted colleges.

Direct Intervention: Canada-France Relations, 1967-1974

Direct Intervention recounts the political and diplomatic courting among Canada and France at a serious juncture in Canada's heritage. As a Minister within the Canadian Embassy in Paris, Eldon Black witnessed a number of fateful occasions - from visits (successful and unsuccessful) of ministers and best ministers among Ottawa, Quebec urban and Paris, to conferences on the Elysee palace, and exchanges of a myriad of telegrams, notes and different diplomatic correspondence.

Additional info for Between Principle and Practice: Human Rights in North-South Relations

Sample text

Dutch policies in Indonesia and Suriname have been criticized in Parliament and by the media. In Canada, the geopolitical significance of a large aid program to China and small aid programs in Central America and Haiti have led to public debate. 54 China is a constant for all three Western states. The Tiananmen Square massacre was a gross human rights violation calling for assertive international action. But each internationalist has significant economic and political interests in China that are likely to complicate human rights statecraft.

Third, because the focus is on Western diplomacy, the case studies had to tackle what the policy makers in each state thought was problematic or salient. "Salience" is a variable that requires explanation. It is partly a function of public concern. In Norway, debates in the Storting (parliament) have focused on Sri Lanka and Kenya, two major recipients of Norwegian aid that have growing human rights problems. In the Netherlands, colonial ties and economic links define the salient cases. Dutch policies in Indonesia and Suriname have been criticized in Parliament and by the media.

It is primarily an instrument of last resort in extreme cases of unequivocal state culpability in the perpetration of deliberate, systematic, or persistent human rights violations. N. specialized agencies or their affiliates, such as the World Bank. An aid bonus should be made available to regimes that are taking visible steps to safeguard human rights. In the current climate of donor fiscal restraint, this seems unlikely, however. Political conditionality is most likely to be successful if applied through sustained donor coordination in aid-dependent economies.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.70 of 5 – based on 42 votes