Eleanor Marx, Volume 2: The Crowded Years, 1884-98 by Yvonne Kapp

By Yvonne Kapp

My experiment, OCR'd

This moment quantity, finishing Eleanor Marx's biography, covers the final fìfteen years of her existence whilst she made a signifìcant contribution to the British and overseas working-class circulate within which she was once significantly enjoyed and remains to be remembered. the entire, with its exhaustive unique study, throwing clean gentle upon and new insights into either deepest and public existence, together with Frederick Engels' final years, and its attraction of fashion, is among the master­pieces of recent historic biography.

“Dear comrade, I will be very happy to talk on the assembly of one November [1890], the extra happy that my father used to be a Jew.”

Any dialogue of the Jewish radicalism of Eleanor Marx, the youngest daughter of Karl Marx, may still commence with this amazing letter. Its unmarried sentence is bursting with historic significance.

First, as her biographer Yvonne Kapp famous, Eleanor’s “awakening satisfaction in her Jewish antecedents” have been “roused… by means of poverty afflicted and persecuted operating classification Jews” that she met in London’s East End.

The assembly were known as to protest opposed to anti-semitic pogroms within the pre-revolutionary Russian empire. a few of the Jews on the assembly could were fresh immigrants who had fled for his or her lives.

Second, Eleanor, by way of posthumously conferring Jewish id on her past due father, was once tough the entire claptrap that has claimed Karl Marx was once an anti-semite.

She was once the person that top knew her father’s attitudes and innermost emotions. the connection among father and daughter was once terribly close.

To confirm, Karl, son of a German Jew who had switched over to Christianity, had by no means expressed any curiosity in his family’s Jewish heritage. And the red passages in his essay at the “Jewish Question” have certainly prompted a lot misunderstanding.

But actually within the 1840s, he have been the major progressive challenging Jewish emancipation in his local Germany.

And he could were as inspired as Eleanor on the emergence of a militant Jewish workers’ stream within the very heartlands of capitalism. as a minimum, Eleanor had an easier explanation for recommending her father during this method. She hoped this viewers could undertake his ideas.

Finally, the assembly have been referred to as within the the teeth of competition from the Jewish institution, in particular the foreign banker, lord Rothschild, who anticipated contemporary Jewish arrivals to maintain quiet and stay away from politics.

It got here at an important second for the socialist flow. the good Dock Strike in 1889 signalled an enormous growth of the alternate union flow between hundreds of thousands of formerly unorganised, unskilled workers.

In an identical yr Eleanor had traveled to Paris with Engels, Karl Marx’s life-long collaborator, to assist determine the second one overseas. They was hoping that workers’ internationalism might locate organisational expression.

This spirit of internationalism fired Eleanor’s enthusiasm for establishing between Jewish staff. not just could the advantages of exchange unionism develop into seen, the following was once additionally an opportunity to teach that Jewish and non-Jewish staff had a standard type curiosity that can conquer all of the previous prejudices of anti-semitism.

And this used to be no longer summary conception. Coincident with the dock strike, 10,000 Jewish tailoring staff had pop out on strike for 6 weeks, final a hundred and twenty workshops.

Eleanor was once a hugely skilled agitator. She were one of many key audio system on the 100,000-strong mass rally in Hyde Park, on 1 September, through the 3rd week of serious Dock Strike.

Will Thorne, Tom Mann and Ben Tillett — the lads who have been development the hot unionism — all paid tribute to her tireless cohesion throughout the strike.

But she had quite come into her personal whilst she shaped the 1st women’s department of the nationwide Union of Gasworkers and common Labourers.

As Kapp writes, she used to be now not at the sidelines, making progressive speeches as Marx’s daughter. fairly, “she was once now a residing a part of operating category action”.

She was once elected to the administrative on the first annual convention of this union “by common acclaim with no vote being taken, so unanimous used to be the welcome, so complete throated the reaction to her nomination”.

Did they care they have been electing a Jewish girl? No, they didn't. What a powerful image that Jews have been welcome within the operating type movement.

There have been many different facets to Eleanor’s existence. Karl Marx’s family had breathed Shakespeare. Eleanor knew complete passages via the age of 4. She had unrealised literary objectives of her personal. whilst, she had a negative own existence which resulted in her early suicide.

But let’s depart her the place she could most likely such a lot wish to be remembered. on the first may possibly Day, Hyde Park 1890, quoting the poet, Shelley, welcoming one of many leaders of Irish liberation circulation and calling for the abolition of sophistication society:

“The unemployed either on the backside and the head of society may be received rid of!”

Show description

Continue reading "Eleanor Marx, Volume 2: The Crowded Years, 1884-98 by Yvonne Kapp"

Revitalizing Marxist Theory for Today's Capitalism (Research by Paul Zarembka, Radhika Desai

By Paul Zarembka, Radhika Desai

Paul Zarembka, Radhika Desai (eds.)

As a couple of alert mainstream and company economists rediscover the yes parts of Marx's research of capitalism, the essays within the first a part of this quantity reveal that they've some distance to head. To their discredit, mainstream understandings even if of capitalism's progress or of Western capitalism's interrelated long term stagnation and financialization are derailed accurately by means of political aversion to, or lack of expertise of, Marxist different types and analyses. The chapters within the moment half expand Marxist insights into assessing the worth of the so-called info, or knowledge-based, commodities, and supply a Marxist critique of Lenin, the one international chief who previous had deeply studied his personal country's economic climate. The half additionally offers vital works in translation. the 1st, learn in Russian by way of Marx himself, increases critical questions about the relevance of Hegel within the knowing of Capital and provides its personal insightful research. the opposite, via a Marxist collective within the Nineteen Seventies demonstrates the centrality of politics and the category fight within the simplistically conceived monetary devalorization of continuing capital. the ultimate half encompasses a debate at the advantages of positivist Marxism sparked via an editorial in quantity 26 of this learn sequence.

Show description

Continue reading "Revitalizing Marxist Theory for Today's Capitalism (Research by Paul Zarembka, Radhika Desai"

Class Struggles in Eastern Europe, 1945-83 by Chris Harman

By Chris Harman

This can be the 3rd variation of Chris Harman’s publication at the ‘People's Democracies’, being a revision of the ebook formerly issued below the name of paperwork and Revolution in jap Europe. It differs from the unique 1974 version through the extension of a bankruptcy on Poland into the ’eighties, and the addition of a 3rd half on idea and views. just like the unique, it's a very precious compendium of proof set right into a convenient old framework, and monitors a powerful command of the resource material.

However, this was once a bonus already loved by means of the 1st variation, and it can't be acknowledged that the extra fabric has made it right into a higher booklet. really the reverse.

For a commence, it indicates a studied forget of contributions written by way of Socialists and Communists of alternative persuasions, a fault no longer relatively so obtrusive within the prior version. one of the works to which no reference in any respect has been made are the mass of fabric now on hand at the post-war purges (e.g. Loebl and Slingova) François Manuel and invoice Lomax on Hungary, Pelikan, Broué and Karalasingham on Czechoslovakia, and the collections of Czech fabric in Voices of Czechoslovak Socialists and Coates’ Czechoslovakia and Socialism, let alone the huge writing on Poland. And the writer is especially selective in his polemics, making no try to solution those that argue for the operating category personality of those states. Trotskyists are bracketed besides Stalinists as “people who nonetheless had illusions, to a better or lesser quantity, within the Socialist (or not less than workers' nation) personality of japanese Europe” (p.321) and Mandel is just quoted to teach his errors (p.102), the author who prefer more straightforward objectives (p.321). yet a few of the arguments used to verify the capitalist nature of those set-ups are very flimsy certainly. whilst the Soviet Union conquered those international locations in 1944-45 we have been informed that “the previous ruling sessions have been in no to place up resistance to Russian demands” (p.20). Why may still they? The facts indicates basically that Stalin used to be desperately attempting to reanimate them, an endeavour within which he needed to admit his failure. The try to distinguish among the pinnacle bureaucracies of those states and the ‘intermediate strata’ rests upon not more stable classification criterion than ‘control’ (p.143ff.). To turn out the lifestyles of capitalism there at one aspect we're given the decisive argument that “a operating category is a weird function of capitalist societies” (p.321). Does the author think, then, that it really is attainable to abolish salary labour the day after a revolution – even in backward nations? And wouldn’t this criterion end up that Lenin’s Russia used to be as ‘capitalist’ as Stalin’s, then? however the greatest piece, without doubt, in view of current happenings in those international locations, has to be the comment on web page 142: “It is rarely most likely, as a result, that old-style, inner most capital might even examine breaking apart Hungarian into small competing devices ...”

Secondly, a comparability of the current version with that of 1974 indicates a unique improvement of the occasion pretensions of the organization that has produced it. even supposing the need for Marxist events in those states is a lesson that may be (and is) drawn all through, we're by surprise brought to a longer commercial for ‘the innovative Party’ within the context of Poland within the ’eighties (pp.312ff.), which, to inform the reality, matches no larger there than wherever else, other than within the feel that it really is close to the top of the narrative a part of the publication, and may good by no means be learn if it were easily consigned to the theoretical bit on the back.

So when being priceless compendia of genuine subject, the executive price of different variants of the e-book, as with Tony Cliff’s Rosa Luxemburg, lies much less of their research of the occasions and extra within the mathematical exactitude in which they degree the ascent of the SWP into sectarian self-proclamation as ‘the progressive Party’.

Al Richardson

Show description

Continue reading "Class Struggles in Eastern Europe, 1945-83 by Chris Harman"

Heart of a Heartless World: Religion as Ideology by Scott Mann

By Scott Mann

My experiment, Non OCR'd, 300DPI

Seeks to give an explanation for the starting place and improvement of faith in social, fiscal and political life.

Review by means of Paul Blackledge
How should still socialists relate to social events whose goals are knowledgeable through non secular rules? A moment’s attention of this challenge is sufficient to recommend basic solution is precluded by means of the very variety of such movements.

The contemporary emergence within the West of a strong present of Islamophobia which has been used to justify battle overseas and authoritarianism at domestic, and of a powerful Islamicist response to this present, has posed the risk that socialists may possibly use crude atheist opinions of Islam to justify siding with imperialism. however, the reactionary content material of many non secular principles implies that socialists needs to stay away from the other risk of portray Islamic competitors of imperialism crimson. Given the complexity of this political context, it really is crucial that socialists have entry to a few rudder through which they could steer a path among both tailing fundamentalism or capitulating to imperialism.

An visible prerequisite for any critical socialist engagement with such hobbies needs to be that we make concrete analyses of concrete events: the actual social content material of any non secular stream has to be the keystone through which we pass judgement on it. With admire to the connection among Islamicism and imperialism famous above, it truly is visible that the most enemy is globalising imperialism. On a extra mundane point, while I sat with participants of an area church team at the educate to final year’s demonstration opposed to the G8 in Edinburgh, the truth that their presence at the demo was once expert via the idea that we're all equivalent within the eyes of god intended that to have opened our dialog with an atheistic denunciation of the assumption of god might were childishly sectarian. instead of take this method, our dialog focused at the challenge of the way most sensible to construct a move to beat worldwide poverty, and that i spotted a distinct radicalisation in their opinion at the method domestic once they had skilled their first mass demo.

Needless to assert, it isn't past the nation-states of the prospective that i would be compelled to confront this couple back in much less propitious circumstances—on contrary facets of the abortion debate for instance—where the reactionary facet in their spiritual ideals could come to put us on contrary aspects of the barricades. this instance is sufficient to recognize that how socialists may relate to this couple particularly, and spiritual hobbies extra regularly, relies at the concrete content material of the events knowledgeable via non secular principles. in spite of the fact that, whereas examples reminiscent of this replicate the ability of an easy intuitive method of such hobbies, it is still the case that we have to transcend instinct if we're to supply a compelling substitute to different perspectives.

For example, in his The God Delusion, Richard Dawkins lends his personal clinical authority to the modern demonisation of that dreaded beast ‘fundamentalism’ while he argues that non secular notion is the most enemy of latest enlightened opinion. If socialists are to head past this sort of one-dimensional denunciation of faith, they should define another framework wherein faith is to be explained.

This is precisely the duty taken up via Scott Mann in his Heart of a Heartless international: faith as Ideology. the start line of Mann’s research, as is clear from the name of his publication, is Marx’s critique of faith. well-known for disagreeing that faith was once the ‘opium of the people’, a line which whilst taken out of context used to be utilized by Stalin to justify his personal ‘war on drugs’, Marx really defined a way more nuanced research of religion.

Whereas Enlightenment thinkers had first pointed to either the falsity of non secular ideals and their position in propping up reactionary regimes, and following from this had, Dawkins-like (first time with grandeur, moment time as farce!), geared toward overthrowing such superstitions with the facility of argument, Marx was once extra drawn to the social foundation of non secular trust. the whole citation, taken from Marx’s creation to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of correct, from which either the above line and the name of Mann’s booklet are taken, reads thus:

‘Religion…is the glorious realisation of the human essence because the human essence has no longer received any actual fact. The fight opposed to faith is, for this reason, in some way the fight opposed to that global whose non secular aroma is faith. spiritual soreness is, at one and an analogous time, the expression of genuine pain and a protest opposed to genuine discomfort. faith is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the guts of a heartless international, and the soul of soulless stipulations. it's the opium of the folk. The abolition of faith because the illusory happiness of the folks is the call for for his or her actual happiness. to name on them to renounce their illusions approximately their is to name on them to renounce a that calls for illusions. The feedback of faith is, consequently, in embryo, the feedback of that vale of tears of which faith is the halo.’

Thus Marx, as Mann exhibits with admirable readability, argued that to fight opposed to faith within the demeanour of Dawkins is at top to tilt at windmills. For if the resource of non secular trust is genuine human discomfort, then to visualize overcoming the previous with out facing the latter is to lapse right into a country of phantasm each piece as incoherent because the trust in god itself. For socialists this could be no mere highbrow blunders. particularly it truly is accurately simply because these on the backside of society are inclined to endure such a lot that they're probably to include faith. To create a barrier among those humans and innovative events via insisting that they discard their ideals earlier than they subscribe to could therefore be political suicide: positive for the proud sectarians who're proud of lifestyles within the political desolate tract, yet disastrous for severe socialist firms that wish to win mass support.

It used to be accurately hence that Lenin was once opposed to making atheism a of club of the Bolshevik celebration: he realised that non secular rules could in simple terms wither away slowly after their resources in human soreness had disappeared. extra typically, Marx’s technique offers socialists with a framework from which they can preserve their independence from spiritual rules, whereas refusing to reify those rules because the key challenge within the sleek international. In a capitalist process marked via exploitation, inequality and conflict, socialists know that faith, like different ideologies, can mirror the critique of those barbarities or turn into an apologist for them, and infrequently can do either while. We as a result interact with spiritual events no longer basically because the embodiment of abstractly fake principles, yet within the mild of ways they relate to those the genuine key difficulties of our age, struggling with along those that carry those ideals in as far as they confront those difficulties, and criticising them in as far as they do not.

Mann’s research doesn't cease with Marx. He makes an attempt to synthesise those insights with others taken from Darwin and, in particular, Freud. If Darwin overthrew spiritual causes of the emergence of lifestyles, and Marx offers a social clarification of why after Darwin many proceed to carry non secular ideals, Mann argues that Freud presents the root for an evidence of ways members come to embody the view of an omnipotent god, and certainly be ready to sq. the assumption in god’s love with a attractiveness of ‘evil’ on the earth. He means that those ideals are a kind of fable wish-fulfilment in adults that function as subconscious defence mechanisms, the resource of which might be traced again to prior youth kinfolk with their parents.

Indeed he makes an attempt to synthesise Marx and Freud by way of arguing that human judgment of right and wrong may be proven to be no subliminal hyperlink to god simply because what's thought of to be correct and flawed alterations through the years. quite judgment of right and wrong is healthier understood as a mirrored image within the child’s eye view of parental authority, and as such is old: because the picture of parental authority evolves over the years so too do rules of correct and fallacious and similar to god.

Mann’s ebook contains interesting discussions of the way a dead ringer for god replaced via background; from the worship of the goddess in pre-class societies in Europe to the overthrow of this faith and its substitute via male gods following the emergence of sophistication societies after the final ice age. He additionally has fascinating issues to assert in regards to the upward thrust of Catholicism and Protestantism, or even an wonderful, if speculative, dialogue of Jesus.

While it truly is unlucky that he doesn't speak about Islam, the theoretical strengths of the ebook make sure that it may act as a big place to begin, complementing books reminiscent of Paul Siegel’s The Meek and the Militant and Michael Löwy’s The struggle of Gods, for a person short of a materialist figuring out of faith. My in simple terms remorse is having no longer spotted its life prior. certainly, since it was once released in 1999 there's a sturdy likelihood that your neighborhood book shop wouldn't have a replica. worry no longer, it's nonetheless in print and Bookmarks can order a duplicate for you.

Show description

Continue reading "Heart of a Heartless World: Religion as Ideology by Scott Mann"

Art, An Enemy of the People (2nd edition) by Roger Taylor

By Roger Taylor

His is a provocative e-book serious about the social value of high-cultural actions. it's a rejection of the position of paintings because the optimum manifestation of society's achievements, exposing artwork because the perogative of elites and an enemy of the people.

Art has no longer been with us for ever. in accordance with Roger Taylor, it really is of contemporary origins; its functionality has been considered one of type domination. the writer argues that philosophy and aesthetics are answerable for illusions approximately artwork which provide traditional humans an unjustified experience of inferiority. while those are penetrated -through historic and social research- the placement of artwork as an enemy of the folks turns into apparent.

Popular tradition is itself at risk of being weakened via makes an attempt to reconcile it to high-culture. Roger Taylor has written for those that wouldn't in most cases learn a philosophy or different publication with highbrow pretensions.

Roger Taylor appears on the historical past of jazz as an instance of the possibility to pop culture. Jazz has been absorbed by means of the cultural institution. it truly is not a conflicting substitute to high-culture and now not a very renowned culture.

The arguments of paintings an Enemy of the folk have been for while it was once written and primary released. Being devoted to this contingency used to be the critique of philosophy which the publication includes. accordingly, in getting ready a moment version, no attempt has been made to replace its arguments. Its arguments have been for then and never now. Arguments for now are contained in Roger Taylor's new booklet Invisible Cells and Vanishing plenty. paintings an Enemy of the folks is a part of the background of anti-elitism and anti-art which built in Cultural thought throughout the latter sector of the 20th century. As Stewart domestic says in his Mute interview with Roger Taylor, "Taylor was once the 1st author I'd encounter whose arguments approximately artwork didn't exude the rotten egg odor of the assumption of God". This publication is then a tough instance from the heritage of Anti-Culture.

--------------------

Biography
Roger Taylor is the writer of artwork AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE(revised variation to be had on Kindle), past artwork (revised version on hand on Kindle from could 2014) and INVISIBLE CELLS AND VANISHING lots (available on Kindle). he's a Marxist thinker whose matters contain the as though, Rethinking Marxism and the Philosophy of break out. He has performed an influential position within the deconstruction of paintings and tradition. For over 20 years he taught philosophy at Sussex collage, united kingdom. quite a few his contributions were released in lots of books and journals. Roger Taylor is the terrestrial kind of the avatar Rumpledsilkskin and INVISIBLE CELLS AND VANISHING lots is their such a lot bold project, made on hand for may perhaps Day 2013. It develops a thought of digital Revolution and a thought of Make-Believe. Roger Taylor plans to submit on Kindle a publication of affection poetry to his spouse and a singular to be known as THE UNHOLY BIBLE. he's additionally writing a brand new, philosophical paintings concerning the idea of realization. every thing he writes is either critical and subversive.

========================

Originally released in 1978, it is a re-creation released solely through Amazon and with a truly short new creation. fascinating, polemical booklet from a real English eccentric.

Show description

Continue reading "Art, An Enemy of the People (2nd edition) by Roger Taylor"

Revolutionary Apocalypse: Ideological Roots of Terrorism by Luciano Pellicani

By Luciano Pellicani

Rising from the cultural disaster produced by means of the nerve-racking increase of modernity, the pro progressive is one disappointed with the realm. Incapable of accepting fact, he/she is confident that he/she has a systematic wisdom that resolves the puzzle of background and should bring about the construction of a paradise on the earth. Pellicani information the background of the beginning of revolutionarism as a brand new kind of Gnosticism via a learn of the idea, the association, and the perform of the Leninist social gathering and their venture to purify society by means of everlasting terrorism. He analyzes the explanations at the back of the cave in of the totalitarian procedure equipped by means of the Bolsheviks, and he presents new insights into realizing the new revival of the nihilistic anarchism of the Black Blocks in Europe and their violent assaults opposed to globalization and glossy civilization.

As Pellicani describes, the aim of the pro progressive is the evangelical neighborhood, in accordance with innovations of equality and common brotherhood. to arrive the specified objective, the innovative sees just one road-a battle of annihilation opposed to the capitalists who're accountable for the corruption of humanity. this can be the resource of the panthoclastic ardour of the Gnostic revolution: the full global needs to be destroyed to reach on the New global, the dominion of God with no God, Paradise on Earth.

Show description

Continue reading "Revolutionary Apocalypse: Ideological Roots of Terrorism by Luciano Pellicani"

Land and Labour: Marxism, Ecology and Human History by Martin Empson

By Martin Empson

My experiment, OCR'd

Review by means of Simon Butler
Martin Empson's 'Land and Labour': A Marxist view of ecology and human history

Martin Empson's first e-book, "Land and Labour: Marxism, Ecology and Human History" was once released by way of Bookmarks in early 2014. Martin attracts on a Marxist knowing of background to grapple with the contradictory power of our courting with our surroundings. In so doing he exhibits that human motion is essential, either to the destruction of nature and to the potential for a sustainable strategy to the ecological crises of the twenty first century.

Ian Angus, editor of the weather and Capitalism site, acknowledged in regards to the e-book that it:

"puts today's international environmental difficulty into old context, exhibiting how humanity has used and abused the remainder of nature for millions of years, and the way in a couple of hundred years capitalism has introduced us to the edge of catastrophe. it's crucial interpreting for everybody who desires to understand how we obtained into this mess--and how we will be able to get out of it."

Simon Butler, co-author of the ebook, "Too many folks? inhabitants, Immigration and the Environmental Crisis" wrote:

"This brilliant publication examines humanity's dynamic relationships with nature - from the sunrise of civilisation to trendy instances - which will higher knowing the social roots of today's environmental crises. attractive, accomplished and extremely well-written, it's an enormous contribution to the sector of Marxist ecology." - Simon Butler, co-author Too Many People?

Writing in Socialist evaluate, January 2014, Camila Royle stated that

"Marxist geographer Neil Smith as soon as argued that, in commencing to increase a historic materialist method of nature, Marx had given us the corners and lots of the instantly edges of a jigsaw puzzle. The task of later generations has been to put out those items and fill within the remainder of the image. This publication is a crucial contribution to that tradition."

Martin is additionally the writer well known pamphlets, "Marxism and Ecology: Capitalism, Socialism and the way forward for the Planet" and "Climate swap: Why Nuclear strength isn't the Answer". he's dependent in Manchester, within the united kingdom and is a protracted status socialist and environmentalist activist.

Show description

Continue reading "Land and Labour: Marxism, Ecology and Human History by Martin Empson"

Collected Works, Volume 49: Correspondence, August by Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels

By Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels

Quantity forty nine: Letters 1891-1892

Marx/Engels gathered Works (MECW) is the most important choice of translations into English of the works of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. It comprises all works released through Marx and Engels of their lifetimes and various unpublished manuscripts and letters. The amassed Works, which was once translated via Richard Dixon and others, includes 50 volumes. It used to be compiled and published among 1975 and 2005 through development Publishers (Moscow) in collaboration with Lawrence and Wishart (London) and overseas Publishers (New York).

The accumulated Works comprises fabric written via Marx among 1835 and his loss of life in 1883, and through Engels among 1838 and his loss of life in 1895. The early volumes contain juvenilia, together with correspondence among Marx and his father, Marx's poetry, and letters from Engels to his sister. numerous volumes gather the pair's articles for the Neue Rheinische Zeitung.

Other volumes within the gathered Works comprise famous works of Marx and Engels, together with The Communist Manifesto, The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon, and Capital, lesser-known works, and formerly unpublished or untranslated manuscripts. The accrued Works comprises thirteen volumes of correspondence by means of the mature Marx and Engels, protecting the interval from 1844 via 1895.

Although the accumulated Works is the main entire selection of the paintings by way of Marx and Engels released so far in English, it isn't their entire works. A venture to submit the pair's whole works in German is anticipated to require greater than a hundred and twenty volumes.

Show description

Continue reading "Collected Works, Volume 49: Correspondence, August by Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels"