Making Every Vote Count : Reassessing Canada's Electoral by Henry Milner

By Henry Milner

Steps towards Making each Vote Count brings jointly the simplest analyses from the simplest certified observers on advancements within the starting to be circulate to reform Canada's electoral system.

Among mature democracies, basically the us and Canada use the first-past-the-post (FPTP) approach for electing all nation and provincial, in addition to nationwide, lawmakers. In Canada the talk over the electoral method, which all started in earnest after the 1997 federal election, is now relocating from the college and think-tank seminar room to the ground of 5 provincial legislatures.

Four key chapters current updated bills of advancements in BC, Québec, PEI, and Ontario. They convey the provinces relocating at diversified speeds towards assembly an goal to suggest a selected version of proportional illustration that still guarantees a endured position for at once elected representatives of particular geographic barriers. chapters recount stories in New Zealand and Scotland, that have followed electoral plans trying simply this kind of stability. Others examine South Africa, Japan, France, and the United Stateseach chosen for the sunshine it casts on a selected element of electoral process reform. the rest chapters reflect on a number of useful implications of adjusting Canada's electoral procedure - now a truly genuine prospect.

Show description

Read or Download Making Every Vote Count : Reassessing Canada's Electoral System PDF

Best canadian books

Becoming My Mothers Daughter: A Story of Survival and Renewal

Turning into My Mother’s Daughter: a narrative of Survival and Renewal tells the tale of 3 generations of a Jewish Hungarian kinfolk whose destiny has been inextricably sure up with the turbulent background of Europe, from the 1st international conflict in the course of the Holocaust and the communist takeover after global battle II, to the family’s dramatic get away and emmigration to Canada.

Alex Lord's British Columbia: Recollections of a Rural School Inspector, 1915-1936

Alex Lord, a pioneer inspector of rural BC colleges stocks in those memories his reports in a province slightly out of the level trainer period. traveling via significant northern territory, using unreliable transportation, and enduring climatic extremes, Lord grew to become accustomed to the aspirations of distant groups and their religion within the humanizing results of tiny assisted faculties.

Direct Intervention: Canada-France Relations, 1967-1974

Direct Intervention recounts the political and diplomatic dating among Canada and France at a serious juncture in Canada's background. As a Minister within the Canadian Embassy in Paris, Eldon Black witnessed various fateful occasions - from visits (successful and unsuccessful) of ministers and best ministers among Ottawa, Quebec urban and Paris, to conferences on the Elysee palace, and exchanges of a myriad of telegrams, notes and different diplomatic correspondence.

Extra resources for Making Every Vote Count : Reassessing Canada's Electoral System

Example text

To revitalize our political parties, Kent favours having the House of Commons elected through a list-style PR system while turning the Senate into a more representative body elected under FPTP. Using the Senate this way is another way to maintain the link between the citizen and a single legislator which, unlike other proportional systems, is achieved under MMP. Lawrence LeDuc reverses Kent's proposal. Why not leave the Commons for now and try PR out on the Senatean institution few Canadians feel strongly about keeping in its present form?

19 If the Liberals could elect MPS in the West and the PCS in Ontario, the argument ran, national unity would be strengthened and no one region would feel that it was permanently relegated to the opposition benches. A government caucus with members from all regions would govern with sensitivity to the entire country, not just the large central provinces which dominate Canadian governments. Of course, the call for reform met opposition along the lines described above. In addition, some, notably John Courtney, challenged the idea of fixing a political problem by changing institutions.

But it only elects 80 district members. So it is awarded 120 additional seats in Parliament, to be filled by the top-ranked candidates on its lists. Conversely, if Party A won 210 of the 250 district seats (very unlikely, but not impossible) it would not be entitled to any additional seats because it would already exceed its quota as determined by the second-ballot results. But the party would keep those extra 10 seats, and the legislature would be (temporarily) enlarged. Each type of electoral systemFPTP, AV, two-ballot, list-PR, STV, and MMPreflects a different set of political values.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.84 of 5 – based on 34 votes